
Having spent the most wonderful day with my BFF we paused during our lunch break to ponder my year ahead as a teacher. It is always great to bounce ideas around with others in the profession and although she has been out of the full time teaching racket for a few years, she is one of the most well read and incredibly informed people that I know. Therefore, any ideas or questions from her are certain to probe parts of my psyche that I had not poked around for a while! She is refreshingly frank and will certainly hold me accountable for the answers that I provide! Probably why I admire her so much!
Anyway, the dreaded moment arrived soon into the conversation as the horrible NS words popped out...oh yes, the question hung in the humid air around us as I pondered my reply. The question was this...
how will the expectations around achieving National Standards affect/restrict the ability to teach in a digital classroom?
(I clawed around for some pithy reply
when in reality I knew that this serious question deserved some serious utterances.
)
Well, first of all I must admit it is a question that I have given a lot of thought to
. The National Standard expectations are all around reading, writing and maths - not the ability to think, question and create ideas. So in reality, the measurable outcomes are all about an aged-based level. This kind of livens things up for us because we are not being measured against norms for thinking skills, inquiry learning or independence. How can we quantify this sort of data? Or can we? Is there really going to be a
tick box that I wind up carrying around to show performance data for my class based on their I.T literacy? Surely not!
BUT...surely there have to be measurable outcomes to justify our use of devices such as iPads, iPods, laptops, video etc. It is not okay to simply slip these into the back door of our rooms and allow them to be toys rather than tools. If we wish to enhance the learning then we must be prepared to somehow justify the outcome.
This is where I feel our classrooms and classes are changing shapes massively. They are transforming into the digital age of child-centred learning with digital portfolios which are driven by the student and summative assessment being usurped by formative and ipsative assessment. Although the need for normative assessment is still there - hence the National Standards making parents feel somehow better - there is much less emphasis around this evident in the classroom.
For example, ask any 20-70 year old what they learnt and why and what control they had of their own learning and the answer is simple. They were TOLD what to learn and when to learn it. They had no control of their own learning. They were set against norms constantly. Pass and fail were the only possible outcomes and written testing was the only means of gathering hard data.
Ask my own children now what they learn and why and what control they have over their own learning and they will use a language which is as foreign to most parents as Flemish.
They will site their
goals. They will reel off a string of ideas around their
next learning steps. They will explain to you how and why they make the choices that they do around their own learning based on what they find
tricky. They possess an acute awareness about their
personal goals and will not hesitate to take you on their
learning journey, but do take care to strap in as they are usually on a wonderful ride!
And so, back to the question of the day - what about National Standards? With this wonderful New (yet old) curriculum and the freedom to direct children's learning through it, and the amazingly learning literate generation we have in schools today, are National Standards a threat to that progress? Or, are we simply going to need to find a way to ensure that they are met without damaging the process of independent learning that we are striving to grow in every classroom in this nation?
The quesiton hangs. And the answer eludes me. But I do believe that the answer lies with the children. They will surely find a way around the problem since we are teaching them to be problem-solvers!